Witching Rush Hour

I had a lot of fun playing it and hacking it. It would be cool if you had a list of passive upgrades somewhere, and it showed you all the potions you collected at the end. If there was some way to get more of the ingredients you want I think it would be balanced better and less RNG dependent. Micromanaging light levels was good. The sweeping blast offset bugged me lol. Anyways, good work!

Witching Rush Hour Gameplay

https://youtu.be/HZ96XoqPA7A

Cool tower defense concept! I had a hard time hitting the enemies sometimes (mostly a skill issue :P lol). I liked the ever-creeping shadow and the potion abilities. I think this could be a cool mobile game if you decided to continue working on it!

I also like the design of your GDD. I can definitely see the Don't Starve inspiration in the pixel art.

This is a fantastic concept and really well executed.

I love the need to balance risk and reward for the ingredients and it implements both themes mechanically.

Really great.

The gameplay has an interesting general premise, though I feel it could have worked better if throw-towards-mouse behaviour was removed altogether in favour of throw-towards-player-direction. As it is, I just ended up placing the mouse in the middle of the cauldron and ignoring it for the rest of the game.

I liked the variety of potions here, although some potions' purpose was unclear (what is "Potion of Supplementary Potions") and I'd sometimes get a repeated one (e.g. "Potion of Feline Vision"). Would be nice if all 25 potions were shuffled, and then if the player manages to get the 26th they complete the game. Also, the potion name could have a brief description below it to explain how it actually benefits the player.

The balancing between the light and darkness was also nice, though I wish the ingredients-spawning appeared a liiittle closer within the ring of light (as in, half-shadow rather than complete shadow?). That, or maybe log-spawning and ingredient spawning would have their own sound effects, so I would know when to add some wood to the fire to search for a fresh ingredient? 

It took a while for a new type of enemy to appear; for a moment there I thought that the hands of darkness will be the only enemy I'll encounter. I eventually survived to see the shooting enemies; they feel kind of overpowered, especially the way they start shooting as soon as they spawn, it seems. ^^'

Props for having an option to change controls - I ended up going for arrow keys + Z/X/C setup, so that one hand takes care of movement while the other does interactions. Too bad the settings don't change between games. Having a local record of the best time would also be nice.

Pretty nice game overall, though it could use some tweaking here and there to make it work better.

A really nice and simple game.

The controls are probably the biggest issue to be honest. I wish the character attacked in the same direction as I was aiming. It feels counter-intuitive to have me aim to throw stuff but not aim with the mouse to attack. So having to line myself up with the keyboard to attack while aiming to throw stuff with the mouse was kinda a pain in the ***.

Other than that I had a great time playing the game. The premise was cool running around throwing ingredients back to the pot felt awesome and I loved the constant struggle of keeping the flame lit while fending off the little "Thing" hands that would dim the flame.

The art and auidio were good too and other than the previously mentioned issue the controls were fine and I had no bugs/issues to speak of :)

So fun to play. Once you get used to juggling items around, you feel like a god.
+ Feels good, man
+ Potions do cool things, and there's a high skill ceiling to play with
+ Difficulty curve is nice and smooth
- Attack hitbox is pretty bad. I lost mostly because I'd be swinging at the same hand several times before actually hitting it.
- Itd be nice to have the potion name onscreen for a bit after I've consumed it; I was rushing too much to read for long.
- Ingredient spawn rate feels a bit inconsistent

Wow, this game was REALLY fun. Everything felt very satisfying to do and the game has some good challenge to it as well! I honestly found myself lost in playing for a sec and was ready to play for a long time haha. Well done!

Really cool game. I really like that some things you need to figure out for yourself e.g. which ingredient goes to make certain potion.

I've managed to get to 4 minutes, difficulty wise the game is nicely balanced. I enjoyed being a witch and slapping hands with my broom

Very cool game! The broom sound effect really sells it.